Review: All the Birds, Singing by Evie Wyld


I picked up Evie Wyld’s All the Birds, Singing on a whim, because I liked the cover design and the tone of the review quotes on the back. I didn’t know anything about the author, and it wasn’t until I was about three-fourths of the way through that I discovered she’d won a lot of literary prizes for the novel. All I knew by then is that Wyld deserved all of those prizes.

I can count on one hand the number of novels I’ve read in the last couple of years where the prose is truly exceptional and the author’s vision has both clarity and substance. In All the Birds, Singing Wyld creates an unforgettable character in Jake Whyte, a woman with a troubled past who, in the present, lives on a farm she owns on a remote British island. The story of her encounters with a strange beast and neighbors she wants nothing to do with is interwoven with a narrative about the past that gradually delves farther and farther back in time.

We learn that Whyte knows a lot about how to shear and care for sheep, a job she’s taken up again by choice in her isolation on the island. We learn that she grew up in Australia and in fleeing her past she got a job at a sheep station in Australia. The scenes in which she is navigating a landscape full of men, many of whom don’t trust her, are riveting and contain brilliant moments of character insight. All of the secondary characters come to life with deft, economical precision, and the bustling sheep station provides a great early contrast to the isolation of Whyte’s life on the island.

But the contrast between these scenes and the ones in the present isn’t just expressed through a shift in tense—the past cleverly presented in present tense—it’s also in the atmosphere. Whyte’s subtle but adept in how the island scenes are slowed by cold and mud while those in Australia are alive with heat; the syntax shifts and adjusts to fit the setting. This is in part a function of conscious thought about style by the author and in part due to first-hand knowledge of both landscapes…or at least this is my impression; perhaps Wyld’s just a really good liar about details of setting.

Wyld’s also not afraid to just give the reader the blunt, brutal truth. There are aspects of Whyte’s past—because of what’s been done to her and what she herself has done—that you get full-on, in detail. To describe them here would be spoilery, in that the life of the novel is in the moment and in the particulars of sometimes fairly brief scenes. But my point is that we begin the novel with a mystery about Whyte—who she is and why she’s now on the island— and on some level the rest of All the Birds, Singing is nothing but exploration of her character, a kind of clear-seeing that creates empathy even through the most disturbing sequences.

The writing in the novel is muscular without being lush or overly descriptive; Wyld knows how to pick her spots so that everything we get counts. A bicep on a scrawny man bulges like “a new potato” during an arm-wrestling contest. Recalling a horrible encounter, Whyte feels like “wax is coating me from the inside.” Trees in a moment of tension “appeared to swell and shrink with the rhythm of breath,” which is perfectly placed after a description of birds rising out of the trees and then settling back in that reinforces the illusion.

As All the Birds, Singing progresses, it’s true that the evocations of the past aren’t always as fresh or new as at the novel’s start—and the conclusion feels much more like stopping than ending, perhaps in part because no matter whether a mystery is about a dead body or a living one the reveal can’t be as compelling as the set-up.

But the clear-eyed self-appraisal present throughout, the evocations of island life and Whyte’s interactions with a mysterious man who shows up at her farm, the utterly stunning set-piece involving her home town and a tragedy…all of these elements have softened my slight disappointment at the end to the point where all I remember are the brilliant things about this novel. Especially in a context where Wyld gives the reader such a memorable, unique, strong-yet-flawed woman as her viewpoint character.

In short, All the Birds, Singing now makes me want to read everything Wyld has ever written.

11 comments on “Review: All the Birds, Singing by Evie Wyld

  1. Colin says:

    Thanks for the recommendation. Reading it now. Wonderful stuff.

    I’ve only read fifty pages but the structure – one strand in the present moving forward, the other in the past moving backward – and set up – someone on the run from themselves – very much reminds me of Iain Banks’ Use of Weapons. As does the clear, crisp writing.

  2. “…very much reminds me of Iain Banks’ Use of Weapons”

    -Colin (up above)

    Really… that’s interesting.

    I’ll take a look at this work on Amazon Sample… I can’t trust anyone where writers are concerned… unless it’s Franzen on the cover of Time or something… one cannot trust the populace’s intelligence too much, especially in these days!

    Luckily we have Mr. Vandermeer to ‘guide’ us with his wonderful new Trilogy!

  3. I have read so many articles or reviews regarding
    the blogger lovers except this piece of writing
    is really a nice paragraph, keep it up.

  4. Janette Hoague says:

    I just finished reading All the Birds, Singing. I must say i was disappointed by the ending. To not find out what had been killing the sheep was a big let down!

  5. Tressa says:

    You should be a part of a contest for one of the best websites online.

    I most certainly will recommend this web site!

  6. Malissa says:

    I see you share interesting things here, you can earn some extra money, your website has huge potential,
    for the monetizing method, just search in google – K2 advices how to monetize a website

  7. A5 Envelope says:

    I pay a visit eveeryday some web sites and websites to
    read articles, except this blog offers quality based writing.

  8. Shoes Online says:

    Right away I am going away to do myy breakfast, wwhen having my breakfast
    coming again to read further news.

Comments are closed.